|
Great Lakes
Article:
Minnesota:
Mercury standard seen as too weak
By Dennis Lien
Pioneer Press
12/16/03
About 900 pounds of mercury that otherwise would be eliminated
will continue to fall across Minnesota annually in coming
years under the Environmental Protection Agency's proposed
mercury-control standard for coal-fired power plants,
state environmental groups contended Monday.
Much of that airborne mercury finds its way into lakes
and streams, where, as a highly toxic offshoot called
methyl-mercury, it accumulates in the flesh of fish and
is consumed by anglers and their families.
"It's not a very good standard and certainly not
strong enough to require any significant reductions in
Minnesota,'' said Matt Little, Sierra Club air toxics
campaign coordinator.
About 90 percent of the mercury that falls in Minnesota
comes from outside the state. In Minnesota, an estimated
3,700 pounds of mercury are released each year. Almost
half comes from coal-fired power plants, which would not
have to cut emissions levels as much as they would under
more stringent limits previously envisioned.
"Coal-fired power plants, the single largest source
of mercury emissions in the U.S., are being given a pass
by this administration,'' Sen. Mark Dayton, D-Minn., said
in a statement.
Over the past decade, many statewide production sectors,
such as sewage sludge and medical incinerators, have reduced
mercury emissions dramatically while power plants have
increased their emissions slightly.
Sarah Welch of the Izaak Walton League of America's Midwest
Office said a compromise reached last week to reduce pollution
at three of Xcel Energy's metro-area power plants would
reduce mercury emissions by 200 pounds a year, about 10
percent of the mercury that can be traced to state energy
production.
Over the past decade, Minnesota has taken a number of
measures to reduce mercury released into the atmosphere.
The state, for example, has banned the sale of many products
containing mercury, requires businesses and households
to recycle fluorescent lamps and has established a 2005
goal of reducing mercury emissions by 70 percent from
1990 levels. The MPCA has agreed not to pursue additional
state regulations until then as long as adequate progress
is made in reducing emissions.
There also are several voluntary programs, such as thermometer
exchanges. In addition, the state puts out fish-consumption
advisories addressing how much and what types of fish
caught in Minnesota can be consumed safely.
Saying that's not enough, however, a coalition of environmental
groups recommended last week that state or federal legislation
shoot for a 90 percent reduction of mercury by 2010 and
a virtual elimination by 2020.
|